Short Film Reviews

 Short Film Review 1:
Lewis Capaldi’s “Someone You Loved”: Directed and Edited by Phil Beastall


Phil Beastall’s music video to Lewis Capaldi’s “Someone You Loved” Beastall P. (2019) is a short film written to raise awareness for an organ donation charity “Live Life Give Life” following the life of a husband looking after his terminally ill wife and a family whose mother needs a heart transplant with their worlds merging when the ill wife becomes the mother’s donor.

The opening shot comprises of Peter Capaldi standing side-on to the camera on a station platform with a train arriving in the distance followed by the camera moving in towards him, causing the focus to pull onto Capaldi. During this sequence, we hear a heartbeat before the film cuts to a shot of a car in a car park and “Someone You Loved” Capaldi L. (2019) starts to play.

Fig. 1

Throughout the music video, we see a mirage of handheld shots following Peter Capaldi’s character through his day-to-day life looking lost and is clearly in conflict with his emotions and most likely the realisation of his future without his wife, this being the antagonist of the story. In contrary we see a mother, father and their daughter living happily along side Capaldi’s life; This is visually hinted at in the shot where Capaldi and the mother pass each other in the park- at the time unaware of their connection.

Fig. 2
Fig. 3

As the film develops, we reach the climax/redemption of the story where we see a final shot of Capaldi’s wife, followed by a sequence of shots with Capaldi in the family’s home and the mother revealing her scar to him and placing his hand on her chest to feel his late wife’s heartbeat within her.

Fig. 4

As the music video declines from the climax, we see shots of Capaldi with his late wife recording her heartbeat through a stethoscope and his headphones, followed by a shot of him with the family and their daughter presenting him a picture with “Thank You for making my mummy better” written on it. This is one of the main redeeming moments within the video as we see Capaldi accepted into this unknown family and smile again.

Fig. 5

As the music fades out the music video cuts back to the station platform with Capaldi standing side onto the camera, this time however, watching the train pull away and the camera pull away from him; we also hear the heartbeat again. This shot choice creates a circularity within the film by starting and ending in the same location in the same way; which in turn gives the story a sense of completion. 
Fig. 6

Fig. 7


The overall ending of the music video makes sure all ends of the story are covered and makes sure the viewer is not left in any sense of confusion or incompletion. 

List of Illustrations:

Fig.1 Phil Beastall (2019) Lewis Capaldi- Someone You Loved [Screengrab] At: https://vimeo.com/316102366 (Accessed 06/10/2021)

Fig. 2  Phil Beastall (2019) Lewis Capaldi- Someone You Loved [Screengrab] At: https://vimeo.com/316102366 (Accessed 06/10/2021)

Fig. 3 Phil Beastall (2019) Lewis Capaldi- Someone You Loved [Screengrab] At: https://vimeo.com/316102366 (Accessed 06/10/2021)

Fig. 4  Phil Beastall (2019) Lewis Capaldi- Someone You Loved [Screengrab] At: https://vimeo.com/316102366 (Accessed 06/10/2021)

Fig. 5  Phil Beastall (2019) Lewis Capaldi- Someone You Loved [Screengrab] At: https://vimeo.com/316102366 (Accessed 06/10/2021)

Fig. 6  Phil Beastall (2019) Lewis Capaldi- Someone You Loved [Screengrab] At: https://vimeo.com/316102366 (Accessed 06/10/2021)

Fig. 7  Phil Beastall (2019) Lewis Capaldi- Someone You Loved [Screengrab] At: https://vimeo.com/316102366 (Accessed 06/10/2021)


Bibliography:

Phil Beastall (2019) Lewis Capaldi – Someone You Loved (2019) [Music Video] At: https://vimeo.com/316102366 (Accessed 06/10/2021)

Lewis Capaldi (2019) Someone You Loved [Streaming] Universal Records. At: https://open.spotify.com/track/7qEHsqek33rTcFNT9PFqLf?si=23f997afc8ad4def (Accessed 06/10/2021)



 Short Film Review 2:

Francesca de Fusco's "Friends Like That"

Short Film Review 2- “Friends Like That”- Written and Directed by Francesca de Fusco

Francesca de Fusco’s “Friends Like That” is a short film that follows a girl who has recently been through a breakup and has visited her ex-girlfriend for comfort and advice. The main protagonist in the video, featured below in figure one, is introduced to us initially crying and saying out loud a heart-felt message to the girl whom she has broken up with. This introduction to her suggests she is lost and very hurt by the events prior to the short film. We learn that she has visited her previous ex-girlfriend for support when she is introduced to us, composing this heart-felt message as an email for her.

(Fig. 1)

Using Alex Glawion’s Short film structure Glawion, A (2021), we can see how this opening sequence strongly sets up the story; within this opening sequence, we are introduced to the main character, our protagonist as well as building a sense of empathy towards her.

Our “Turn of events” happens when we are introduced to our protagonist’s prior ex-girlfriend who she has visited; this is not a normal everyday occurrence, and we see as the piece starts to develop that there is tension in their relationship. Within this sequence, we are also introduced to the stories “call to action”; this is when our protagonist continues saying her message and says, “I guess, what I’m trying to say is, I have to look for, what I tried looking for in you, I have to look for within myself.” This acts as our “call to action”, as it shows how our character has realised, they are lost within themselves and need to find themselves before they can find someone else. We are also introduced to the fact that our protagonist and her friend’s relationship fell apart in much the same way which again creates a tension and leads the story into its main “quest”.

(Fig. 2)

The stories main quest is our protagonist finding herself. In this second act, we see our protagonist at first struggle to find motivation after receiving a phone call from her ex; we see her attempt to go for a run but decide not to which is followed by the protagonist lying in bed with pornography playing on her laptop. - These two scenes act as our “crisis” according to Alex Glawion’s Short film structure Glawion, A (2021). Our protagonists “personal growth” is introduced when she discovers Arts and craft; as shown in figure three. She is seen smiling and talks her friend through what she has made. I believe this is a metaphor for her finding herself and who she is as this scene clearly shows how she has dedicated time to herself and successfully completed a fulfilling activity that she is proud of and acts as a form of ‘self-help’ to our protagonist.


(Fig. 3)

The stories “Showdown” comes as the short film moves into its third and final act. The protagonist is in the bath and her friend is sat beside her, reading a self-help book to her; during this the protagonists phone vibrates and it’s a message from her ex- Her friend reads the message to her and then writes a ‘joke’ reply to the message; this causes a stir, and the protagonist gets out the bath and they both end up on top of each other. As mentioned earlier, the two characters have a past, and this comes back to the story in this moment as they start to kiss. Under the suggested short film structure by Glawion, A (2021), this would be the stories resolution, however the writer has decided to create a new turn of events for the ending rather than a resolution. This comes when the ‘joke’ text message accidently gets sent while the two characters are making out on the floor; this causes our protagonist to walk off camera and is seen in the ending shot sat on the stairs with her ex calling her, but not being answered.
Although this ending goes against Glawion’s structure, I believe it creates a narrative loop, bringing the audience back to how the story started, with the protagonist sat surrounded by problems around her ex. However, this ending doesn’t satisfy the closure of the narrative and leaves many branches unresolved, if anything creates more branches to be solved.

List of Illustrations:

Fig. 1 Francesca de Fusco (2020) Friends Like That [Screengrab] At: https://vimeo.com/626069696 (Accessed on 14/10/2021)

Fig. 2 Francesca de Fusco (2020) Friends Like That [Screengrab] At: https://vimeo.com/626069696 (Accessed on 14/10/2021)

Fig. 3 Francesca de Fusco (2020) Friends Like That [Screengrab] At: https://vimeo.com/626069696 (Accessed on 14/10/2021)

Bibliography:

Francesca de Fusco (2021) Friends Like That (2020) [Short Film] At: https://vimeo.com/626069696 (Accessed on 14/10/2021)

Glawion, A (2021) Perfect Short Film Structure: How successful short films structure their story At: https://www.cgdirector.com/short-film-structure/ (Accessed on 14/10/2021)




 Short Film Review 3:

Rayka Zehtabchi & Sam Davis' "Are You Still There?"

Rayka Zehtabchi and Sam Davis’ “Are You Still There?” is a short film that follows a girl (Safa) who, on the way home suffers a breakdown and gets stuck in a car park. Safa is the main protagonist in the video, featured in figure one below; she is introduced to us in the opening clip of the video, driving while singing; she appears care-free and relaxed from her driving physicality.

(Fig. 1)

Using Alex Glawion’s Short film structure Glawion, A (2021), we can see how the short films opening sequence strongly outlines the story; we are introduced to our main protagonist, Safa, and although we are not directed to establish any feelings towards her, we get a clear sense of her personality and emotions in this sequence.
The stories “turn of events” is alluded to when we see Safa parks up her car and leave to go to the shops; although Safa leaves the shot the film sticks with the dashboard shot with the audible alert tone ringing in the background whilst the world continues around the car. As time passes this alarm starts to die off and the story cuts to Safa returning. This is where the “turn of events” occurs; Safa attempts to start her car and it doesn’t start. This creates a barrier she must overcome if the story is to follow Glawion, A (2021)’s film narrative structure.

Throughout the second act of this short film, the narratives “call to action” is built up and attempted, however there are many hurdles put in the way to stop this happening to make the narrative richer. Our “call to action” is Safa watching a ‘How-To’ video on jump starting a car; however, throughout the second act, the vision of fixing her car gets further and further away from the audience. The first hurdle is the recurring shop owner who shouts and yells at Safa for being parked in the car park too long, pointing at a sign and saying she’ll get her car towed away- this scene recurs throughout the second act until Safa finally tells gets the women to understand her situation. 

The second hurdle is her call to the AAA, the roadside assistance service. During this call Safa is made aware she is not actually under her fathers account and therefore they won’t come and help her. This second hurdle however also presents our “call to action” to the audience, where Safa watches the ‘How-To’ video and then calls her mum for help and to come to jump start her car. This is when the third and final hurdle is presented, her phone dies.
At this point, towards the end of act two, we see Safa at her lowest; she has been beaten by her situation and has lost all hope. We see Safa crying in her car when the shop owner that had previously been shouting at her approaches with a drink for her. The narrative then jumps in time to see Safa sat in the shop/café, charging her phone, eating, and then seeing her mum arrive outside; this is the narratives “call to action” starting to take shape.


(Fig. 2)

During this next sequence, the narrative shows both Safa and her mother struggling to jump start the car but bonding through the experience; they both seem to have limited technical knowledge but are trying hard to fix it. As act two comes to an end, Safa and her mother are sat in their cars, waiting for Safa’s battery to recharge when they talk about her dad; during this segment they way they talk about her father adds an extra depth to the narrative as it suggests he is no longer around (however I was unable to determine the reason for this i.e., being through divorce or death).

After this scene, Safa starts her car and her and her mother share the moment and bond; after this the narrative moves into act three. 

The narratives “resolution” comes in the form of Safa trying on the flat cap she found in the back of the boot after the conversation with her mother about her father and memories. I therefore concluded that this flat cap has a connection to Safa’s father. While she tries the hat on, Safa becomes happy and contempt and then places the cap on her dashboard to mimic a ‘mascot’.

The narratives “Shutdown” comes in the form of Safa saying goodbye to her mum, getting in her car and driving off. In this scene, the final clip is used to create a narrative loop, replicating how the short film started with a shot through the windscreen watching Safa drive, back to her care-free and relaxed personality. This is often used to create a sense of completeness for the audience which I believe is the intention here.

(Fig.3)

List of illustrations:

Fig. 1 Rayka Zehtabchi & Sam Davis (2021) Are You Still There? [Screengrab] At: https://vimeo.com/592973112 (Accessed 22/10/2021)

Fig. 2 Rayka Zehtabchi & Sam Davis (2021) Are You Still There? [Screengrab] At: https://vimeo.com/592973112 (Accessed 22/10/2021)

Fig. 3 Rayka Zehtabchi & Sam Davis (2021) Are You Still There? [Screengrab] At: https://vimeo.com/592973112 (Accessed 22/10/2021)

 

Bibliography:

Glawion, A (2021) Perfect Short Film Structure: How successful short films structure their story At: https://www.cgdirector.com/short-film-structure/ (Accessed on 14/10/2021)

Rayka Zehtabchi & Sam Davis (2021) Are You Still There? (2021) [Short Film] At: https://vimeo.com/592973112 (Accessed 22/10/2021)

Comments

  1. Lewis,

    You’ve done great work to identify the Story structure and how Joseph Campbell’s ‘Heroes Journey” can be applied to certain events during the film, clearly explaining the arc from beginning to end. The one issue here is that you have described it as Alex Glawions’ structure, rather than Campbells. Although Glawion is the Author of the article cited, it is Campbell’s structural method he is referring to.

    You’ve also clearly explained the emotional arc experienced by the Character, and have interpreted not only the explicit information given to you, but detailed an understanding of the subtext that is given throughout the film and have made reasonable, logical conclusions based on this. e.g.

    “The narratives “resolution” comes in the form of Safa trying on the flat cap she found in the back of the boot after the conversation with her mother about her father and memories. I therefore concluded that this flat cap has a connection to Safa’s father.”

    Overall, you’ve made a clear and concise review, fulfilling the aim of analysing the structure of both plot and Character within the film.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Workshops & Completed Film

Screenwriter Research

Script Breakdown