Analysis of an Observational Documentary
For my analysis of an observational documentary, I have
chosen the BBC’s “The Railway: Keeping Britain on Track” series.
Released in 2013, it was a six-part, single camera documentary series looking
at the state of the Britain’s trains and railway network, following the days of
staff from different regions of the country, what they endure and the reality
of their jobs, as well as getting passengers comments and experiences. I will
be focusing my analysis and research on Episode 1, titled “King’s Cross”,
directed by Laura Fairrie.
As someone who travels frequently across the UK, the documentary
was automatically of interest to me; I found its storytelling approaches interesting,
each episode focuses on a different region/time of year/ train company; it will
have a select few members of staff from varying different backgrounds it will
follow throughout their days and tell the story of the area, its railways, history,
and problems through these members of staff. I found this approach created more
of a personal link to the documentary, that an approach of just “shooting” and
seeing what unravelled wouldn’t have created. I feel the approach taken by the crew
on the documentary follows the ideas presented in “The Shut Up and Shoot” book,
by Artis, A. Mainly, “Choosing a location with characteristics that
help tell your story, don’t just choose a spot at random.”
The episode I studied used the staff members stories as storytelling
devices; leaning into the staff’s previous experiences to show the history of
the station. They also used the staff’s current experiences to tell the story
of the new station opening. They also used the accompanying music to help tell
stories, using low/sombre toned music to accompany sad scenes and upbeat music
for happier/cheerful scenes.
From watching the series fully, I found that the director
has chosen to use mainly hand-held shots throughout; the only shots that seemed
to be on a tripod were B-Roll clips, but even most of those were hand-held. Personally,
I feel this visual and aesthetic choice makes the audience feel more connected
to the film- the shakiness makes them feel it is their point-of-view and they
are actually there; this further aids to the storytelling and emotional
connection the audience have to the staff and their stories. The crew use a lot
of wide shots to establish the locations, as well as cut-aways to aerial footage
and B-roll to make the story all feel connected and flow, when it is likely
these stories are not closely linked by time due to the nature of filming. In relation to my groups documentary, I feel this documentary is too "public orientated" and "spur of the moment" filming approach, which would not suit my group's documentary as we have a structured story.
In conclusion, I feel the documentaries choice of storytelling
approaches and devices help to create a strong and coherent narrative to the
episode, accompanied by the visual choices to create emotional links between
the audience and stories presented.
Reference List:
Wikipedia (2013) The Railway: Keeping Britain on Track
At: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Railway:_Keeping_Britain_On_Track (26/04/2022)
The Railway: Keeping Britain on Track Episode 1: King’s Cross
(2013) At: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FJtnfv1N80I
(Accessed 11/04/2022)
Coffman, E (2009) “Documentary and Collaboration: Placing the
camera in the Community” In: Journal of Film and Video 61 (1) pp62-78
At: https://www.proquest.com/docview/2170581/fulltext/52CAB32C4BA44936PQ/1?accountid=14178&forcedol=true
(Accessed 26/04/2022)
Artis, A (2014) The Shut Up and Shoot (2nd
edition) New York: Routledge At:https://www-taylorfrancis-com.ucreative.idm.oclc.org/books/mono/10.4324/9780240824444/shut-shoot-anthony-artis
(Accessed 26/04/2022)
Comments
Post a Comment