Analysis Of A Relevant Doumentary

 

For my analysis of a relevant documentary, I have chosen “4.1 miles”.
4.1 miles is a heart-breaking short documentary, directed and produced by Daphne Matziaraki, it follows the story of a coast guard captain on the small Greek island of Lesbos who is suddenly in charge of saving thousands of Afghanistan refugees from drowning in the Aegean sea.

The documentary tells a heart breaking and harrowing story of the reality of the European Migrant crisis in 2015-2016 where criminal smugglers put the lives of thousands of refugees at risk. Over 600,000 migrants crossed the 4.1 mile stretch of water between Turkey and the Island of Lesbos in the 2015-2016 period, with Lesbos being an un-equipped, small, Greek island. The local community brought it upon themselves to save the lives of these poor refugees who have had their lives turned upside down.

The documentary is a single camera film, filmed mainly as a point-of-view piece apart from the limited B-roll cutaways. An interesting storytelling device used is the lack of voiceover/pieces to camera in the entire film; the main storytelling comes from the audience witnessing the devastation with no interruption- hearing the screams and cries of despair of the refugees fighting for their life in the sea, and the desperation and will of the coast guard men, risking dangerous sea conditions to save as many lives as they possibly can. This choice of storytelling device I feel creates more of an emotional and powerful narrative, it makes the audience very aware of the situation and pulls at the heart strings. The clever use of audio helps this; the mix will have long periods of the video clips audio and then occasionally drop to having a music accompanying the clip- I believe this is also used to help create the emotional story that needs telling by the coast guard team.

The film’s visual and aesthetic choices are very cleverly used as a storytelling device, all the “action” shots are handheld and very shaky, giving the feel that one of the coast guards have filmed it themselves. This places the audience on the boat directly with the crew and makes them feel emotionally emersed in the horrible action that is unfolding. We also occasionally see the camerapersons hand appear, creating the awareness of the person behind the camera and thus further placing the audience on the boat. The film uses very little talking directly to camera shots, and focuses mainly on the action, as well as the B-roll being very shaky, gritty and “raw”; this further shows my previous idea of placing the audience on the boat with the crew. This does however raise an ethical dilemma as the cameraperson is watching this unfold and only in a limited number of cases do we see them help the crew, something as the audience we are begging them to do. This idea is presented to us in the Journal of Film and Video by Coffman, E, “The “shoot first, explain later” approach” which ‘ has a necessary place in documentary practises… as long as filmmakers are conscious of the ethical implications.’

I found this documentary very moving and emotional, it isn't a topic or a narrative I would often find myself drawn to, nor is the style of the piece a style I would normally find myself drawn to; however, I feel that this style is perfect for this documentary as it is what creates the narratives edge and what makes it so hard-hitting. 
In terms of my group's documentary, I do feel this style would be a possibility for an approach to take in terms of the lack of narration or voice over, however, we are wanting to detract from the idea of a camera-person, which '4.1 miles' doesn't necesarily do. 

In conclusion, 4.1 miles uses many storytelling approaches that are presented to the audience through the visual and aesthetic choices in order to create a very emotional and powerful narrative of great world-wide importance of being told in the very raw and heart breaking way that has been achieved by the documentaries film makers.

 

References:

4.1 miles (2016) Directed By Matziaraki, D. [YouTube] At: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hjnj5B2GCvc (Accessed 26/04/2022)

Wikipedia (2016) 4.1 Miles At: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/4.1_Miles (Accessed 26/04/2022)

Coffman, E (2009) “Documentary and Collaboration: Placing the camera in the Community” In: Journal of Film and Video 61 (1) pp62-78 At: https://www.proquest.com/docview/2170581/fulltext/52CAB32C4BA44936PQ/1?accountid=14178&forcedol=true (Accessed 26/04/2022)

Artis, A (2014) The Shut Up and Shoot (2nd edition) New York: Routledge At:https://www-taylorfrancis-com.ucreative.idm.oclc.org/books/mono/10.4324/9780240824444/shut-shoot-anthony-artis (Accessed 26/04/2022)

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Workshops & Completed Film

Screenwriter Research

Script Breakdown