Project Evaluation
Prior to starting Year One, I was most looking forward to
the documentary unit; it is something I feel very passionately about and
something I have considered as potential career path; I have however, found the
unit very challenging for a variety of reasons. It was also a very valuable
learning experience; giving me many opportunities to experience group working,
how to manage difficult situations and conflicting personalities.
Since the get go of the unit, my group had encountered
issues on choosing the topic of the documentary to fit the BBC Three and
Post-Covid brief. This is a natural point of conflict; opposing ideas and
viewpoints will always create tension, especially if people feel passionately
about what they are pitching. During this process, everyone in my group had very
different ideas- these ranged from exploring how hospitality has been affected
by Covid, A look at how the film industry is working post-covid and following
the production of a film in Margate, How the use and selling of drugs has
changed since covid and how “naturalists” and the industry surrounding them has
been affected and adapted. Although potentially the two that could fit the brief
the best, the latter two were ruled out due to either their potential risk/harm
during production or their sensitive nature and the requirement or potential of
filming in settings that would require extended consent and data security. The
first two also presented issues, the first idea we felt would not be a ‘challenge’
to produce and would no stretch ourselves as a group, something we all felt was
necessary, and the second being a similar data security issue as well as the
requirement to be approved within another production which would require Data
Protection and Non-Disclosure Agreements to be signed by and crew that were not
already employed by the production as well as the need to restrict who saw the
final product due to its sensitive and revealing nature for the production that
would yet to be publicly available by the end of our production period. We
eventually settled on a previously undiscussed idea which was to investigate
the humanitarian aid that communities in the UK are providing to refugees and people in Ukraine
affected by the war, with an aim to encourage more people in our briefs age
bracket to help those in need.
This idea was brought about by a find of a potential contributor for the
project; a mechanic who was building a 4x4 ambulance to donate to Ukraine. I personally
feel that although there was conflict during the process, the process went well.
All members of the group pitched ideas and supported each other’s ideas, trying
to find work arounds when ideas looked unfeasible, and was also able to discuss
and concerns in an open and friendly way.
Now we had an idea, we started the process of creating roles
for the duration of the production. Initially I was assigned as a researcher
during pre-production, a camera operator during production and the editor
during post-production.
As a researcher, I reached out to an
employee from Arriva Buses who had organised for some buses to be donated to
carry donations to Ukraine and then bring orphaned children back to the UK who
I was in contact with until early May; this contact fell through during a
change of direction in the production which will be explained later my
evaluation. I also contacted a professor
at the University of Kent who specialised in humanitarian aid and sociology; he
unfortunately declined to contribute as he did not feel he has the correct
knowledge to comment. I also contacted a local Member of Parliament to act as a
counterargument to Hollie's contributor of a Conservative Party Member of
Parliament; I unfortunately never received a reply from this contributor.
After a week of these roles being assigned, our director took the decision to
step down; Although I do not feel confident directing and it is not my preferred
role, I filled this position to enable our group work to move forward. This meant
that for a short period, I took on less research work while I worked on the Treatment,
pitch and script.
I felt I struggled to create the directing documents (Treatment, pitch and
script); Out of all the ideas we had discussed during the idea stage, this was
the one I felt least confident in- as our feedback said, it is a very ambitious
topic to take on that is very much in ‘the now’ and is also very sensitive. This
feeling made it hard to create the vision that was needed to take the piece
forward and made me struggle with the above-mentioned documents.
Looking back with hindsight, I feel I should not have put myself up to fulfil
the role of director. My personality doesn’t align with that of a ‘natural
director’; I am rather introverted, I don’t like conflict and I am also not
good at being able to act in a way that is needed to delegate roles, make sure
there is a workflow and to direct everyone on how to approach and navigate challenges.
I am however more of a people pleaser, and I always want to strive to make my work
and my groups work the best it possibly can be; I also don’t like to see a
group be let down or struggle- this being the main reason I took up the role of
stand-in director in the first place. Although I don’t feel confident
directing, it is something I want to practise more; I feel I need to work on my
personality traits to make myself more resilient and well-rounded; I would however
approach the role differently next time and would also prefer to be directing a
project from the get-go; I found directing someone else’s idea and previous
work much more difficult than directing my own work like I had done in the
Directing unit previously.
After completing the initial director’s pre-production
work, I went back to adding to the groups research list. I found and contacted
Mid-Kent College about their business students who had organised a donation
appeal for Ukraine, who unfortunately never replied as this was one of the contacts,
I felt would take the narrative far. I contacted Quex Park and Quex Barn who
organised a Thanet-wide appeal for donations and had successfully completed two
trips in a van full of donations to Ukraine; they too unfortunately never
replied, as well as contacting Maidstone Grammar School regarding their WWII
air raid tunnels to obtain B-roll who were kind enough to facilitate this with
us.
In reflection to the research phase of production, I have found it a sharp learning curve. I was unfortunate
that most of my contributors fell through, with many not replying to our
contact with them. I have learnt that you must be relentless and not be
dismayed when contributors fall through. I also gave me a perspective of how
many contributors are needed for such a broad documentary idea; this would
therefore lead me to narrow the idea in a future attempt to help make the
workflow manageable for everyone involved with the production.
I also feel that the change to me being director hindered the progress of the
groups research. I feel things may have got lost in translation and information
was not shared between members of the group which set up problems during the
production phase.
Something I tried to set-up while director was a central shared area to share all
our research, mainly so myself as director could access all the research to be
able to create the narrative for the documentary. This idea was met with some
conflict with other members of the group as they felt they were having to do
more work that was not benefiting them. Although I see their viewpoint, I feel
that as a group project, it is vital that information like this is shared with
everyone in the group.
As mentioned in a Tutorial I had, this is an example of opposing personalities,
something that I am not comfortable with at this time; as mentioned earlier, I
do not like conflict, and I am not good at negotiating work arounds for points
of conflict such as these. This is something I want to work on in future units
and would change in hindsight for this unit.
The production process
presented many challenges that had to be overcome; As director, I felt the project
was ‘hijacked’ by the previous director that had stepped down after they had
gained a promising contributor. The information about the contributor was not
shared with some members of the group, myself included which made creating the
correct narrative very difficult- When asked for this information, I was again
presented with a lot of resistance. This created a lot of tension within the
group and unfortunately inadvertently splitting the group into two. From this
point on, I felt rather excluded from filming opportunities as well the
information that I desperately needed to continue fulfilling my role as
Director. At this point I felt that I was no longer director and that this had
been again taken over by the previous director.
This is something that in hindsight, I should have approached differently; I
should have declared this and took steps to make sure I was included and took
back creative control of the piece, however with a mixture of out-of-uni
commitments, the above events as well as falling ill for the final three weeks
of the unit and being limited by how much I could do, I took the decision to
step down as director. This is something I do partially regret but I do still
feel like this was the right decision for my health as the stress of the
situation at the time was causing me to struggle along with being ill. This is something that I would change if I
was to repeat this unit without my previous circumstances, however.
During the rest of the
production process, I unfortunately took part in one shoot which was to film
B-Roll at Maidstone Grammar School which was also unfortunately not used in the
final documentary. I am disappointed at this as I feel I have not gained the
experience of filming the main aspects of documentaries. This was partly to do
with me being ill and unable to make any potential shoots but was also party
down to the ‘split group’ that we faced at this point, with the other side of
the group not sharing or giving us any chance to make filming opportunities. This
skill is something I want to work on outside of Uni to make sure my skillset is
still robust and has everything I should have in it.
During post-production, I was
meant to be the main editor, however the two that had done most of the filming
wanted to make the main edit as they felt it was a ‘personal passion project’
at this point, as well as my unstable health condition meaning my availability
was limited to participate in a group edit. I personally feel I was left out of
the edit despite trying to involve myself; Although I understand the other two’s
perspective, I feel that again this was a miscommunication and a conflict of
personalities and a victim of the tension present in the group. This tension is
something I tried to work on improving during this process. My main attempt at
this was a discussion to try and involve myself in the edit, which I presented
to them as trying to help with their workload. I ended up doing visual effects
and the credits for them. Although this wasn’t much, I feel it helped me
develop my skills, especially within Adobe After Effects which has helped me
progress. I am also happy that I was able to ease and relieve some of the
tension that had built up in the group.
As a final evaluation of the
final film and the project as a whole, I feel that although it had many ups and
downs, I have learnt a lot from this unit and developed many skills that I can
take forward into future units and group work. I feel that I need to work on my
approach to conflicting personalities as well as my communication skills to
make future group work projects run more smoothly.
Although the final film is not the original we set out to make or that I
planned for as director, I feel it is a moving piece that has a strong
narrative and conveys a strong message to the audience. I am disappointed the
original idea that I had planned for was never finished, but I feel given my
personal circumstances, this was a better outcome.
Comments
Post a Comment